SubExpress & Pizza Primo

Experience delicious Italian subs and pizza at SubExpress & Pizza Primo in Sister Bay, WI. Enjoy friendly service, fresh bread, and flavorful dishes in a welcoming atmosphere. Call +1 920-854-6700 today!

Welcome to SubExpress & Pizza Primo

Signature Dining Experience

SubExpress & Pizza Primo
SubExpress & Pizza Primo
SubExpress & Pizza Primo
SubExpress & Pizza Primo

Located at 2579 S Bay Shore Dr in Sister Bay, WI, SubExpress & Pizza Primo stands out as a haven for food lovers. This restaurant specializes in a delightful mix of Italian dishes, subs, and pizza that keeps patrons coming back. Known for the friendly staff and inviting atmosphere, it’s more than just a place to eat; it’s a community gathering spot. Whether you are dropping by for a quick lunch or a relaxed dinner with friends, you'll find an engaging environment here.

The rich aroma of fresh-baked bread and sizzling pizzas fills the air, making you feel right at home. Notably, Thursday lunches draw crowds, making it the most popular time to visit, but those seeking a quieter dining experience can find best times later in the week.

Location & Contact

Address

2579 S Bay Shore Dr, Sister Bay, WI 54234, United States

Phone

+1 920-854-6700

Social Media

About

SubExpress & Pizza Primo
SubExpress & Pizza Primo
SubExpress & Pizza Primo
SubExpress & Pizza Primo

SubExpress & Pizza Primo serves up a distinctive dining experience wrapped in a friendly neighborhood vibe. Established in Sister Bay, it quickly became a go-to spot for locals and visitors alike. The restaurant's warm environment fosters a sense of community; diners often chat over shared tables, creating a communal dining experience. Patrons rave about the selection, which features everything from classic Italian slices to innovative sub sandwiches.

The all-day breakfast menu, including bagels and eggs, keeps guests energized throughout their busy days, providing quick yet satisfying meals that cater to morning cravings. Amid the lively ambiance, the dedicated staff works tirelessly, ensuring every visitor feels welcomed and valued. Hear laughter and lively conversations mix with the sizzling sounds from the kitchen, creating an inviting environment.

Offering a mix of favorites, the four types of pizzas, including 12” and 16” options, ensure there’s something for everyone, even picky eaters.

As Sister Bay flourishes as a tourism hotspot, SubExpress & Pizza Primo serves as a culinary anchor, bringing people together through shared meals. Special events and team gatherings often take place here, showcasing the restaurant’s ability to accommodate larger groups. The menu's thoughtful variety allows for plenty of customization—mix and match pizzas, subs, and shakes to create the perfect meal. Locals often recommend trying the Italian sub alongside a milkshake; it’s a hit in the community. The commitment to excellence shines through every plate, resonating with the patrons who walk through the doors.

Work Hours

  • Sunday6:30 AM-9 PM
  • Monday6:30 AM-9 PM
  • Tuesday6:30 AM-9 PM
  • Wednesday6:30 AM-9 PM
  • Thursday6:30 AM-9 PM
  • Friday6:30 AM-10 PM
  • Saturday6:30 AM-10 PM

SubExpress & Pizza Primo thrives on its diverse menu, catering to every taste. The restaurant offers all-day breakfast sandwiches, mouthwatering appetizers like cheese curds and wings, and a wide variety of subs. In total, patrons can choose from 53 different dishes including vegetarian options and classic Italian plates. Each dish prioritizes quality ingredients and flavor, making every bite satisfying. The restaurant emphasizes prompt service, ensuring that you're never waiting long to enjoy your meal. Outdoor seating provides a relaxing option for diners wanting to soak up the Sister Bay sun, while the interior boasts a cozy charm that invites long conversations over good food.

SubExpress & Pizza Primo

SubExpress & Pizza Primo welcomes diners with an appealing exterior that hints at the culinary delights within. The charming facade complements Sister Bay's scenic views, making it a pleasant stop while exploring the area. Outdoor seating allows guests to dine al fresco, soaking up the sun while enjoying their meals. The vibrant atmosphere transcends mere dining; it’s about making connections as families and friends gather over shared plates. During the summer months, lively dinners stretch late into balmy evenings, blending laughter, conversations, and the delightful clinking of dishes.

Customer Reviews

The gentleman that was working the evening of the 11th of October was so very kind and attentive, he was a one man show, making pizzas making subs checking people out at the gas station register, give him a raise and some more help. It was busy in there!

K
Kim G.

Im working not far from your amazing sub kitchen, and your Italian sub is the best of its kind that I've ever had! It starts with the amazing bread!!!! It's absolutely amazing all the way around, and I can't wait to eat ANY other sub that you guys make! DELICIOUS IS AN UNDERSTATEMENT!!!

Z
Zachary O.

Our crew loves this place! The bread is awesome.

P
Pool E.

Fresh ingredients, countless options - sandwiches, wraps, flat bread, pizza, etc. - for lunch and dinner, friendly smiles, and fair prices. I'll be coming back again and again for sure. Definitely try a baked wrap for a new twist on healthy lunch.

P
Phamily

Good food, friendly staff, reasonable prices. I've had a club sub, pizza sub, and a chicken salad sub (my favorite!). I liked the large size cheeseburger too. All were excellent!

S
Scott S.

Great food, especially with reasonable prices. Handmade pies are awesome and made local. Appreciate being able to get food at a later hour.

M
Mindy L.